According to California law, how should an attorney handle threats to bring disciplinary or criminal proceedings in a civil dispute?

The correct response emphasizes the ethical obligation of attorneys to maintain professionalism and integrity in their practice. According to California law, attorneys are prohibited from using threats of disciplinary or criminal proceedings as a means to gain leverage or advantage in a civil dispute. This principle is rooted in the moral and ethical standards that govern legal practice, which prioritize fairness, honesty, and respect for the legal process.

Using threats in this manner would violate the attorney's duty to uphold the law and maintain respect for the legal system. Such conduct can undermine the integrity of the legal profession and can potentially lead to disciplinary action against the attorney in question. Overall, attorneys should engage in good faith negotiations and represent their clients' interests without resorting to inappropriate tactics that may compromise their ethical responsibilities.